This weekend, Phoenix Coyotes forward (and former Edmonton Oiler) Raffi Torres attended a team Halloween party with his wife. The couple dressed like Jay Z and a pregnant Beyonce Knowles, complete with darkened skin. Unsurprisingly, there are people who don’t think that’s okay. Also unsurprisingly, and infinitely more depressing, is that there are a lot of people who think it’s perfectly okay, that people who were upset by it are wrong and making something out of nothing. Some of these people have asked if people would be offended if black people dressed up in whiteface (Answer: Not very much, though they hated the movie) or if Torres had dressed up on a poncho and sombrero, itself ignorant of the fact that Torres is of Mexican and Peruvian descent, so if anyone could dress up as that stereotype and claim clean hands, it could possibly be him.
I don’t think Torres is racist. There’s zero evidence that he actually dislikes black people, and I’m inclined to believe part of the defense of him that’s cropped up, which is basically that he’s not racist and that his costume was intended to be a genuinely admiring one. However, I’m also surprised that Torres, who has weathered disgusting racial slurs and stereotypes his whole life, wouldn’t stop somewhere along the way and think, maybe this will sends the wrong message to some people. Because whether or not it’s a minstrelsy show - which it wasn’t - and whether or not he meant it as blackface - which I don’t think he did - someone of light skin darkening their skin to appear black will always bring up the spectre of blackface. In a sense, it doesn’t matter whether Torres meant for it to be blackface because to thousands of people it will be, and being ignorant of that absolves Torres of racism but not of a certain degree of racial insensitivity.


